The CW Source

Great podcast this week! I laughed so much you guys are so funny. What a great episode. Well done to Chad!!! although a bit cheesy in parts just loved it:)

Chad's episode was one of the best. Sarah I knew you'd be singing someone's praises as soon as Mouth died I just didn't know whose it was.

Dan did fire the gun but I thought that it would have been better if Peyton got shot in the leg just like before.

OMG I was just dying to say that same thing Jackie. About the whole Nathan/Haley role reversal this was done so great. And the rain is so significant for the Naely sxenario because back in season 1 it's when they first kissed.

I thought Dan's moutasche was drawn on like when he was eating. he's just like the godfather don corleone. lol

I thought it would have been great to see Deb pining and flirting with Dan.

Mia I don't think that Lucas is like Horatio well maybe they have the same kinda hair. lol And Mia I still watch CSI Miami good thing for me is that they don't clash.

Peyton at the end I was shocked I don't even know what's going on there. But I hope she's ok Sarah thanks for the biology lesson but I don't think I've seen that on Grey's Anatomy, Private Practive or House.

I can totally see Peyton being a hippie acting like Austin Powers well sorta just being all groovy. lol

Jackie I loved your imitation of Lucas. It was dead on

This has been my fave podcast yet it was just awesome. I haven't laughed so much in ages. Sarah you should make your catch phrase " I know!" you said it quite a few times this podcast and the way you said it was just funny. great podcast oh and I'll def be back next week. lol

There were 3 of joy's songs... the one in the beggining, Mrs.Scott (when naley were on the bed), and scheming star(when they were dancing in the bar) she wrote them all..

OK now Joy did AMAZINGG! she was the best one and her and paul were the only ones who actually pulled the 40s episode off. she sang amazingly and looked the best! i loved her in it..

the dan and haley scene was aweosme.. haah lol when they kissed and then she smacked him that was hilarius!

hilarie and sophia and james and chad all disappionted me :(... julian, mouth, skillz all did better than them.

naley was AMAZINGGG, i think that chad did an amzing job with them, there scenes were awesome and i saw the chemistry again.. although Joy is really the aggresor now. JAmes dosent seem to be putting forth a lot of effort in thier scenes anymore :(

dude and i loved it when peyton died... i lolved that part, maoo i laughed soo hard. her acting was just bothering me all night so it was nice when she didnt talk anymore...

but i get what your saying with the future episode.. like seeing peyton with a kid and lucas, future naley and jamie.. brooke with another big fashion line. nathan a big NBA star and Haley a big singerr, it would be cool but they should wai... maybe next season

and LOLto sarah saying im gonna name all my kids chad micheal murray... :) LOL

ok seriously i just have to say again.... I LOVE YOU GUYS!!! listening to these is like one of the highlights of my week lol. you crack me up. i loved the part where i think it was jackie saying "they should go to all the decades and do the 50's and 60's and so on" and everyone was all into it then she said they should do one in the future and it got dead silent lol. so funny!

but i seriously can't believe mia said that CMM looked like david caruso cuz my family has thought that for since like the 3rd season!!! they really do look like father and son haha they both squint and have the same mannorisms and stuff so i just thought that was crazy that she said that.

but i really liked the episode and i thought joy stole the show she was great. it did bug me that lucas called peyton "pretty girl" at the beginning cuz that's what he used to call brooke but it didn't totally turn me off of the episode. it was nice to see something different and i thought it was way creative. it did bother me how their accents faded in and out tho lol.

i didn't think peyton was pregnant (WARNING... SPOILER COMING!) until someone put a comment on the other board and announced it without giving a warning!!! seriously, i hate that. if you're going to put a spoiler down on a comment please give a warning or something cuz not everyone wants to know things ahead of time!!!! but now that i know since someone told the world, i agree with sarah that it could be eptopic lol cuz i watch ER and know what that means and i thought it was way funny that u guy's were sayin thanks for the biology lesson haha.

but yeah that's my opinion for this week. thanks again for the podcast ladies, love hearing your thoughts!!

Hey I thought your podcast was great, I've never left a msg before, but I always enjoy your podcasts and this was no exception. Enjoyed the show after I got over my inital upset of having it interrupt the regular plot. Thought the actors did a decent job (even Hilarie Burton) I know some didn't care for her acting. But I thought it was a fair portrayal; just like a heroine of that era of film, which I love!

LOVED IT!!! BEST EPISODE EVER!!

CHAD DID AN AMAZING JOB!!!!

Chad you did a great job!! :)

But I'm really disapointed that you wrote "the pretty girl" for Peyton and Not Brooke. That was really uncool. Why did you have to take that from us? You take everything from us, I'm pretty sure soon we'll don't have anything left.

And the episode almost became "One Leyton Hill", it was all about LP... A little bit boring.

but otherwise it was good, I liked the Naley scenes and Mouth and Dan were awesome! So was Haley!! <3

Although I wish sophia should've got more screentime...

Worst episode of my life. I have watched the previews for next week like 10 times so far. I refuse to watch this episode again it was that horrible.

...I don't even want to go into why I hated it; I don't want to think about it.

The only thing I loved, and I have to say loved loved loved, was that instead of covering Sophia's beauty mark with makeup like normal, they let it hang out and I think even darkened it. Perfection.

The first thing I said about Peyton though was ectopic pregnancy. Agreed, oldest trick in the book. But she looked fine enough to yell at Mia next week so unless she's yelling out of being so upset about being preggers then I doubt she is/was.

I can't anymore this BrucasxLeyton debate.

Get over yourselves, people!!!

I'm not going to really comment on the episode cause I already left a comment on the episode review, but I just want to say that no matter how much I disliked the episode this podcast was hilarious. I was cracking up the whole time. Sarah I knew you would LOVE that Mouth died, when it happened I actually said, "Sarah is going to be thrilled." And Jackie the maxi pad thing LMAO, that is priceless. I'm quite surprised that you girls liked it so much, but i get where you are coming from. I just couldn't stand it, it was way to cheesy for me (and I can do cheese, seeing as I love the High School Musical trilogy). The only two people who were great were Joy and Paul, the rest of them totally failed in the acting department, and it was just blah. I was expecting so much more. But I'm glad you girls enjoyed it, and I can't wait til next week.... Sarah I think you could be on to something with the ectopic pregnancy, I was thinking miscarriage but it could be either one. Who knows? I guess we will find out!

PS: Since next week is the last episode til January, will you 3 start podcasting s2 over the hiatus? PLEASE!!!!!

I just read a review of the episode that took the words out of my mouth...this part especially:

"Haley owned the screen when she walked on. She had that Rita Hayworth girl-next-door sex appeal and her voice has never sounded better. Kudos to actress Bethany Joy Galeotti. She obviously researched the era because her delivery was pitch perfect. It was like Haley stepped out of a black and white movie."

By Jaime Kawamoto

Best. Episode. Ever

They just decided to forget s1-3 and start writing an episode. And I hvae never felt so disrespected before! Like being stomped on!! They just dropped BL, nothing!! And we BL fans have waited for a long periode for something , just a good friendship scene but so far anything. And this episode just made everything worse. This was the finaly cut, Mark say bye bye to all the BL fans who watch the show!
And what the hell is Chad doing writing Lcuas to say "Pretty Girl" to Peyton!? Everyone one know that that is what Lucas called Brooke, not once not twice but many times.
And it pisses me off that episode story is based on the first three season, while we don't get anything on BL, besides Lucas saying to Brooke that they were good! Serioulsy they were freaking awesome! And the Leyton storyline BUGGED me!!!! Og my god!! They take a walk home and suddenly they are all in lvoe and are going to elope!? WTF!! Naley this episode iget. They had moments they had their eyes on each other for a long time. But Leyton, WTF!! Suddenly Peyton is all needdy (Thanks Chad for pointing that out) and all over Lucas, and he is like a morron,,, hum hum hum; You are pretty Peyton!!! Grrr!
the only thing i liked was Naley, they were awesome

-----------------------------

Found this article on a forum, and I just needed to post it here
Written by Dawn (livelovelaugh):

ok first of all haters shut up this is my opinion so i cant be doing with people debating with me or whatever if you dont agree with what i say thats fine =) jus keep it to yourself

ok so it starts and i hear the line " Hey pretty girl so me natrually being a brucas fan thought awwww hes talking to brooke but wtf he was talking to peyton. That first line alone showed so much disrespect to the brooke and lucas fans and i think after that line the show will loose a hell of a lot of viewers. The LP/BL fanbase is pretty much 50/50 he is gonna loose viewers no matter what but to disrespect the fans like that is just plain rude.

The first Brucas scene. I admitt it was cute it showed the old brooke her fashion her expensive taste and classic brucas chemistry/flirting and brucas fan or not you could see it.

Haley and Dan ........... well what is there to say the only two people who actually remembered to act. i really enjoyed haleys singing and how they portrayed her sexiness. haley i always think has been overlooked as a character people dont really care about her and again in this episode haley and naley were both overlooked by leyton. what else is new?

Leyton started off well good chemistry with the eye glances etc but then went downhill whats with them making peyton dumb all of a sudden. " do you think im pretty? " not only was that a joke to peytons character but to the leyton relationship peyton is not dumb even in that episode she new fine well she was gourgous.

Brooke well just why? why turn her into the bitch of tellin on LP when she has always supported them. even after all the pain they caused her she is still hbappy with them. AU or not why change the characters interpritations?

This was just an episode of leyton i think they are trying to convince the audience that leyton are epic. Yes leyton was epic in that episode there storey was great if that was a film and nothing to do with oth of course i would ship them they were sweet and adorable. but that was let down with the bad quality of the acting. it was a joke and yes ive said that a lot about this episode. but chad looked aso he was falling asleep everytime he spoke. and hilarie was it jus me or did she totally change her accent in that episode? and when she died oh please i hope peyton never dies just so i dont have to see hilarie doing a death scene. Hilarie isnt that great of an actress at the best of times but she can act but that was just a let down. and then to top it all off naley had a foot pop kiss what the hell was that? i jus dont get what was running through there heads when they made this episode for chads first attempt it was good but god i never want to see this episode again. but i did like how peyton fell to the floor at the end i think it is a good way to bring the pregnancy in to the show (sorry if you didnt know about that)

i am one of the only brucas fans who still enjoys oth even with leyton together but i HATED this episode with a passion.

so anyway that was my rant on that episode i have so much more to say but i might get offensive lol

--------------------------------
Found this article on a forum, and I just needed to post it here
Written by Dawn (livelovelaugh):

ok first of all haters shut up this is my opinion so i cant be doing with people debating with me or whatever if you dont agree with what i say thats fine =) jus keep it to yourself

ok so it starts and i hear the line " Hey pretty girl so me natrually being a brucas fan thought awwww hes talking to brooke but wtf he was talking to peyton. That first line alone showed so much disrespect to the brooke and lucas fans and i think after that line the show will loose a hell of a lot of viewers. The LP/BL fanbase is pretty much 50/50 he is gonna loose viewers no matter what but to disrespect the fans like that is just plain rude.

The first Brucas scene. I admitt it was cute it showed the old brooke her fashion her expensive taste and classic brucas chemistry/flirting and brucas fan or not you could see it.

Haley and Dan ........... well what is there to say the only two people who actually remembered to act. i really enjoyed haleys singing and how they portrayed her sexiness. haley i always think has been overlooked as a character people dont really care about her and again in this episode haley and naley were both overlooked by leyton. what else is new?

Leyton started off well good chemistry with the eye glances etc but then went downhill whats with them making peyton dumb all of a sudden. " do you think im pretty? " not only was that a joke to peytons character but to the leyton relationship peyton is not dumb even in that episode she new fine well she was gourgous.

Brooke well just why? why turn her into the bitch of tellin on LP when she has always supported them. even after all the pain they caused her she is still hbappy with them. AU or not why change the characters interpritations?

This was just an episode of leyton i think they are trying to convince the audience that leyton are epic. Yes leyton was epic in that episode there storey was great if that was a film and nothing to do with oth of course i would ship them they were sweet and adorable. but that was let down with the bad quality of the acting. it was a joke and yes ive said that a lot about this episode. but chad looked aso he was falling asleep everytime he spoke. and hilarie was it jus me or did she totally change her accent in that episode? and when she died oh please i hope peyton never dies just so i dont have to see hilarie doing a death scene. Hilarie isnt that great of an actress at the best of times but she can act but that was just a let down. and then to top it all off naley had a foot pop kiss what the hell was that? i jus dont get what was running through there heads when they made this episode for chads first attempt it was good but god i never want to see this episode again. but i did like how peyton fell to the floor at the end i think it is a good way to bring the pregnancy in to the show (sorry if you didnt know about that)

i am one of the only brucas fans who still enjoys oth even with leyton together but i HATED this episode with a passion.

so anyway that was my rant on that episode i have so much more to say but i might get offensive lol

Bethany did 3 songs in the episode. =D
Scheming Star, Mrsn Scott and Karen's Cafe aka. Hotel Cafe.

Haha, when Mouth died, I totally thought of you guys. HAHA.

Does anyone know what happened to Peyton at the very end when she was in her office?

first of all, you ladies are absolutely HILARIOUS!! i loved the maniacal laughter throughout and agreed with most of what you said... i think the episode was a little cheesy, but it was a dream, so it's ok :] and i think peyton will probably think she has cancer (because her birth mother died from it) but she'll actually be pregnant... but it definitely could be an ectopic pregnancy! the only reason i know what that is is because christina had one on grey's anatomy :]

Haley had three songs in the end if you were paying close attention.

Karen's Cafe.
Mrs. Scott.
Scheming Star.

They're really great and they're available on iTunes. I highly recommend her music.

You ladies really surprised me with your responses to the episode. A lot of people did NOT enjoy the episode and it just left them thinking what the fuck just happened? But I thought it was great and simply because of Joy and Paul...Chad's writing not so much. They fit the role and regardless of the chesse-tastic script they most consistently made it work. The have amazing chemistry too, btw.

Unlike Hilarie Burton, bless her soul. She didn't deliver last night and it was painful to watch most of her scenes especially when she was on the bridge yelling for freedom and love...some of her line deliveries are just so bizarre and awkward.

BEST PODCAST EVER! The maxy pad tidbit was what pushed me over the edge in laughter!

OMG I loved the episode and the great cinematography and all of the great throwbacks to past seasons.

And you're right Dan was pretty much the best part of the episode.

I loved all the Chad love from Sarah! That was sooo unexpected lol.

Peyton's death scene was one of the most bittersweet moments of the show.

I'm just so surprised, this is like the only podcast that was unaminously loved!...

By far my favorite episode of the season!

And my favorite podcast you guys have ever done!

I agree with you guys, I can't complain about one thing about this episode. It was well written, witty, funny, good hearted, and all around a winner.

Kudos to Chad, and kudos to this stellar podcast.

I'm anxious to see what's going on with Peyton. Cancer...pregnancy....bad chinese food? Who knows at this point what that was about.

omg LOVEDDDD it!!

best ep ever!!

chad is god! cant stop thinking about this ep, so much happened! loved naley, all the character (ep DAN) was fab! omg it was soooooo good! still soo happy. and ur podcast was great. p.s bethany had 3 songs!

AMAZING!!!

Aside from the beatings Brucas fans like me took last night on several occasions, I actually enjoyed the episode. Chad did a good job. Naley was my favorite. I loved Dan and his eeeeeeeeevilness (that's for you Sarah). Mouth was hilarious! "I'm going places Luke! Where am I going?!" LOL! Brooke had no money, and she still was selfless, in true Brooke fashion.

hey
i loved this episode. it was exiciting (and a little bit cheesey). there is an article about one tree hill in the new entertainment mag with twilight on the cover. you should check. ( it would be tragic if what happens in the article was true about nanny carrie)have fun and remember... we will always have tree hill city(lol)

I absolutely ADORED this podcast! I couldn't stop laughing all the way. And as all three of you I LOVED this episode too! I just have one criticism, it would have been sooooooo much better in black and white. I can't wait for the next podcast!